In actuality the only evidence that. Othello has to prove her infidelity is the handkerchief that Iago places in Cassios house, and of course the words of Iago, whom he believes he can trust. His perception and conclusions are replaced by fury and hatred. Othello is too late to realize what hes done, and consequently this results in many lives lost, including his own. Othello allowed his passions to rule over reason, and for that he paid, to him, the ultimate sacrifice. Although, othello was naive and wrong to put his trust in Iago without the presence of any real evidence, he did so partly because of his low self-esteem. Othello was one of very few black men in Venice and Desdemona was a very young and very beautiful white woman.
Who is responsible for Othello s downfall?
Desdemona would never even think of cheating. Othello, and confirms this in Act 4, Scene 3 when she says, beshrew me if I would do such a wrong for the whole world. Even though Desdemona is a virtuous and innocent creature. Othello still comes to believe that she is a whore who has slept with Cassio while married to him. Othello doesnt show himself to be a jealous person at the beginning but through Iagos manipulation, we see the emotion work at full force. Deceived by iagos skillful lies and convincing techniques, Othello must face emotions he cant handle. Whenever he thinks of Cassio or his wife, an image of the two making love to each other. His jealousy literally drives marathi him mad. Othello becomes so enraged with the thought and even the sight of her that in Act 4, Scene 1 he calls her devil and strikes her in public. In fact he becomes so enraged with her that in Act 5, Scene 2 he states, yet she must die, else shell betray more men. Later in that scene he proceeds to smother her to death.
In answering the question, iagos role in the tragedy cannot be underestimated, however, Othellos mind being so open to direction from others poses the unanswerable question, would these events have unfolded anyways, without Iagos presence? Iago was partly responsible, but the main fault lies in Othellos mistrust of his wife and inability to dismiss idle scandal for what it really. Prompts Iago to plot the ultimate lined downfall of, othello. Jealousy is the most corrupting and destructive of emotions and is demonstrated throughout this drama by the protagonist, Othello. As the play progresses, we watch its vicious influence on the protagonist with compassion and horror. Othello allows Iago to make him suspicious about Desdemonas intentions in wanting to help Cassio to get his position back. Othello, look to your wife; observe her with Cassio; She did deceive her father marrying you. In reality it was Iago himself who told Cassio to ask for Desdemonas help in the first place.
He claims Othello is the most romantic figure among Shakespeares heroes. He does not belong to this world. In the literary sense of the word romantic Othello is incredibly apt. Romanticism is all about extremes of emotion, the emotional triumphing over the rational and can often be quite self-obsessed, as is Othello. Bradley would argue that Iago is completely responsible for Othellos downfall, as the general is too passionate and trusting for this world, which i interpreted to mean he could not function correctly. This view is partly reasonable, as without Iagos calculating skill, Othellos downfall may never have taken place. William hazlett describes Iago as an aesthete evil, a traditional Machiavellian and a personification of rationality. This description enables the reader to view the outcome of the play as rationalitys win gender over emotion, however as the idea of romanticism and rationality versus emotion did not develop in literary criticism until the eighteenth general century, caution must be used when applying these values.
It can be argued, however, that Othellos jealous nature is not his ultimate tragic flaw, but is his saving grace, as such extremes of emotion as Othello feels are surely to be commended as rarities, the emotional side conquering the rational, logical side of the. Admittedly the performance ends in catastrophe, yet it could be argued this is not due to the freedom and speed of changes in his emotional states. Othellos character experiences these complete emotive states throughout the play, firstly with love for Desdemona, but I do love thee! And when I love thee not, Chaos is come again. Then later in the play with jealousy, it is not words that shake me thus! At the end of the play in act five scene two when he learns he has killed the sweetest innocent that eer did lift up eye, he is overcome with yet more emotions, this time grief and self-loathing, Blow me about in winds! Roast me in sulphur! Wash me in steep-down gulfs of liquid fire! Ac bradley would defend these swings of emotion with vigour.
Othellos Downfall - international Baccalaureate Drama - marked
Without Iagos constant disguised manipulation, the generals mind would not have started its journey down the path of jealousy. One critic who disagrees with this view is fr leavis. He argued that Othello is responsible for his own downfall, and personal that Iago is merely a subordinate character and not the main reason for the tragedy. This view is certainly worth considering. Eliot also criticises Othello, accusing him of self-dramatisation, a terrible exposure of human weakness.
So was it Othellos weakness which ultimately led to his downfall? He certainly has several flaws in his character, he is gullible, and fails to suspect Iagos treachery. This however, can be easily defended by the fact that none of the other characters realise either, a testimony to iagos skill in the manipulation of language to his own ends. If not stupidity, perhaps jealousy is his downfall? It is unbelievably easy to see that Othello loves his wife with all his heart, and then hates her with the same degree of passion when Iagos jealous thoughts are allowed to poison his brain.
Although these requirements society has. Othello do not help matters, and are party responsible for the tragic run of events, there are still more factors to consider before the question can be answered. Iago is most certainly one of the aforementioned factors, as, like prospero manipulates the entire case of The tempest using his supernatural abilities, so iago uses his own magic, the powers of language as a medium of communication, to control the characters. This is where, othello deviates from the paradigm of Shakespeares other tragedies; this play is not simply about one mans fatal flaw, but about Iagos manipulation. Iagos trickery of all the other characters is made possible by the fact that they all perceive him to be honest and good Iago.
The number of times he is referred to with these adjectives before his name in the play is laughable, and would have generated a great deal of enjoyable dramatic irony to please the audience. This relates to the Shakespearean theme of deception, the idea that what you see, and what truly exists is completely different and often totally unrelated to each other. This again links with the society at the times obsession with reputation. Nobody mistrusts Iago because of his impeccable appearance and social status, and nobody attempts to look any deeper beyond this. Samuel Coleridge said Shakespeare presents a being close to the devil, with motiveless malignity. This can be argued against, as Iago does give the audience some flimsy excuses for his plot, however I do not believe these are his true reasons for the destruction of Othello.
Othello is Solely responsible for his Downfall
Also, the daddy hypocrisy of the society took its toll upon. He ascended to the high social position of General by killing many on the battle field, yet using these skills he is valued most highly for apple whilst in mundane reality is murder. Othello does not seem to understand the dividing line between killing in battle, and murder. This is hardly surprising, as in the play we see his two incompatible roles of General and husband clash upon many occasions. An example of this contradiction would be when Desdemona is trying to set a date for dinner so that. Othello and Cassio can overcome their differences and. Othello replies, i shall not dine at home. I meet the captains at the citadel.
Who is responsible for, othellos downfall? For you, for Only.90/page order now. What I can do, i will; and more i will, Than for myself I dare, then Iago would not have been able to manipulate. Othellos mind in the carefully constructed web of alibis deceit he had planned. The culture and values of society at the time cannot be allowed to escape without blame. The patriarchal society of the time, in which womens lives were as highly regarded as womens right to free speech cannot have helped. Othello thought he was doing society a favour by murdering Desdemona in case she betray(s) more men. This kind of self-apotheosis was brought on by the societys obsession with honour and reputation, which caused. Othello to develop a desire to maintain his status so badly, that he killed his wife to.
Othello and keeping his trust for the state needs him as he is the best general in Venice. There are several characters that I consider to play a part. Othellos downfall, one of which is Desdemona. Othellos fatal flat was jealousy, then it could be said that Desdemonas was generosity. Othello dismisses Cassio as his lieutenant, desdemona, sensing the injustice assures Cassio she will do all that she can to help, i will do all my abilities in thy behalf. This kind mistake is what allows Iago to plant the seeds of doubt. Desdemona refuses to let, othello have any peace from her constant requests that Cassio be reinstated, Ill intermingle everything he does with Cassios suit, which is not a very pleasant thing to do to her newly wed husband, and the first cracks in their union. If it was not for Desdemonas kind nature, helping Cassio more than she would herself, we will Write a custom Essay sample.
But he is not used to ordinary life through being brought up in a regiment and not as a civilian. The sibilance 'seem so' used in Iago's soliloquy creates a hissing sound portraying Iago's true evil and devilish nature as he plans to reverse. However, Othello who has almost no experience about civilian life is oblivious year to iago's plans. As the audience we see evidence for this when. Othello describes Iago with the post-modifying adjectives 'honesty' and 'truth'. Another tragic convention is the protagonist's reversal of fortune. Othello's fortune is high competent status as a general, and he is shown much courtesy from the state, we can see this in the pre-modifying adjective 'brave' which has ameliorative connotations of respect.
Essay on The valiant moor Othello s Downfall - 578 Words bartleby
578 Words 3 Pages, the term mini of address 'valiant moor' is used by the senator and conveys the idea that. Othello is the protector and saviour of Venice. Othello is a black man of a very high status and can be see as valuable and indispensible to the state, as he is needed to fight in the war. The fronted conjunction 'but' shows that. Othello unfortunately, has a fatal flaw of being very open with those he thinks he can trust on face value alone/. Othello's devotion and love to desdemona in Act 1 could lead him to becoming jealous very easily of his wife. Historically, venetian women were considered loose and so it is easier for Iago to sow the seeds of doubt. In addition to, othello's flaws, he has complete trust in Desdemona this can be seen show more content, the declarative 'the moor is of a free and open nature that thinks men honest when they do but seem so' shows. Othello's other weakness among a few where he believes in appearance therefore thinking he can trust Iago.